| Platinum | Au Vieux Duluth |
| Platinum | Tauro Restaurant |
| Gold | Edward's Bistro |
| Silver | Casa Paolo Ristorante Italiano |
| Bronze | Philos Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jet Set Pub |
| Top Pick | Kelseys Original Roadhouse |
| Top Pick | Sheep's Head Bistro |
| Top Pick | Table 21: Steakhouse & Oyster Bar |